No data
IGBT and MOSFET are fully controlled devices and are voltage-driven, that is, the device is turned on or off by controlling the gate voltage. In fact, the structure of the IGBT is an NPN-type MOSFET plus a P-junction, that is, an NPNP structure, which is a P-type BJT driven by MOS in principle. So what is the difference between them? What is the specific connection of them?
MOSFET BJT or IGBT - Brief Comparison
Catalog
MOSFET is a metal-oxide-semiconductor field effect transistor, or metal-insulator-semiconductor. The source and drain of it can be swapped, and they are both N-type regions formed in the P-type backgate. In most cases, these two regions are the same, even if the two ends are reversed, it will not affect the performance of the device. Such devices are considered symmetrical. According to the polarity of its "channel" (working carrier), MOSFET can be divided into two types: N-type and P-type, usually also called NMOSFET and PMOSFET, abbreviations including NMOS, PMOS, etc.
IGBT (insulated gate bipolar transistor), is a composite fully controlled voltage-driven power semiconductor device composed of BJT (bipolar transistor) and MOS. Have the advantages of high input impedance of MOSFET and the low on-voltage drop of the GTR. When the GTR saturation voltage is reduced, the current carrying density is large, but the driving current is large; the MOSFET driving power is small, the switching speed is fast, but the on-state voltage drop is large, and the current carrying density is small. The IGBT combines the advantages of the above two devices, and the driving power is small and the saturation voltage is reduced. In simple terms, an IGBT is equivalent to a thick base PNP transistor driven by a MOS.

Figure 1. N-MOSFET Architecture
Since the differences between IGBT and MOSFET in structure, working principle and application range are quite detailed, it is impossible to express clearly in one sentence. Next, we will compare the differences between silicon (Si) IGBTs and silicon carbide (SiC) MOSFETs in detail.
The electrical parameters and characteristics of Si IGBT and SiC MOS drivers are quite different. The requirements for driving of SiC MOS are also different from those of traditional silicon devices. They have the characteristics of low on-resistance and small switching loss, which can reduce device loss and improve system efficiency, and more suitable for high frequency circuits. It is widely used in new energy vehicle motor controller, vehicle power supply, solar inverter, charging pile, UPS, PFC power supply and other fields.
The difference between the two is mainly reflected in the GS turn-on voltage, GS turn-off voltage, short-circuit protection, signal delay and anti-interference, as follows:
|
Characteristic |
Si IGBT |
SiC MOSFET |
Drive Requirements |
|||
|
Switching Frequency |
Low, >30kHz |
High, 50~500kHz |
1) Use high power gate resistors. 2) Optimize the cooling environment. 3) Improve the efficiency of the DC-DC conversion circuit and reduce the overall loss of driving power. |
|||
|
Threshold Voltage |
5V-6V |
1.6V-4.5V |
Negative pressure shutdown/Miller clamp to prevent false turn-on |
|||
|
Switching Time |
300ns |
50ns |
1) Use digital isolation driver chip, the signal transmission delay can reach 50ns, and it has relatively high consistency, and the transmission jitter is less than 5ns. 2) the low transmission delay push-pull chip is selected. |
|||
|
Switching-On Time |
15V |
15V~22V |
1) Priority is given to stabilizing the negative voltage to ensure that the shutdown voltage is stable. 2) A negative voltage clamping circuit is added to ensure that it does not exceed the standard during shutdown. |
|||
|
Switching-Off voltage |
-15V~-5V |
-5V~0V |
||||
|
Short-Circuit Withstand Time |
<10μs |
2~5μs |
A diode or a resistor string is used to detect short circuits, and the shortest short-circuit protection time is limited to about 1.5μs. CMTI |
15kV/μs |
100kV/μs |
1) The common mode anti-interference ability reaches 100kV/μs to transmit the isolation chip for signal transmission. 2) The optimized isolation transformer design is adopted, and its primary side and the secondary side are shielded to reduce mutual crosstalk. 3) The Miller clamp is used to prevent the influence of the switch of the same bridge arm. |
For a fully-controlled switching device, configuring an appropriate on-off voltage is of great significance for the safety and reliability of the device. Due to the difference between IGBT and MOSFET, the requirements for the two are also different.
IGBT is a field-controlled device whose turn-on and turn-off are determined by the voltage between the gate(G) and the emitter(E). The working principle of MOS tube (enhancement mode NMOSFET) is to use VGS to control the amount of "induced charges" to change the condition of the conductive channel, and then to control the drain current.
1) Silicon IGBT: Silicon IGBTs of various manufacturers have the same turn-on and turn-off voltage requirements.
· The typical turn-on voltage is required to be 15V.
· The shutdown voltage value range is -5V~-15V, and customers can choose the appropriate value according to their needs. The common values are -8V, -10V, -15V.
· Prioritize stable positive voltage to ensure stable turn-on.
2) Silicon carbide MOSFET: Different manufacturers have different switching voltage requirements:
· The turn-on voltage is required to be higher than 22V~15V.
· The shutdown voltage is required to be higher -5V~-3V.
· Prioritize negative voltage stabilization to ensure stable turn-off voltage.
· Increase the negative voltage clamping circuit to ensure that it does not exceed the standard when it is turned off.
The switching device has the risk of short circuit during operation, and configuring a suitable short circuit protection circuit can effectively reduce the damage caused by the short circuit during the use of the switching device. Compared to Si IGBTs, SiC MOSFETs have shorter short-circuit withstand times.
1) Silicon IGBT
The time of surrender and short-circuit of Si IGBT is generally less than 10μs. When designing the short-circuit protection circuit of it, set the detection delay and corresponding time of short-circuit protection to 5-8μs.
2) SiC MOSFET
Generally, the short-circuit withstand capability of SiC MOSFET modules is less than 5μs, and short-circuit protection is required to work within 3μs. A diode or a resistor string is used to detect short circuits, and the protection time is limited to about 1.5μs.
1) The impact of high dv/dt and di/dt on the system.
When the switching action is performed under the condition of high voltage and high current, the switching of the silicon carbide MOSFET device will generate high dv/dt and di/dt, which will affect the driver circuit. It is very important to improve the anti-interference ability of the driver circuit for the reliable operation of the system. the following way to achieve.
· Add common mode choke coil and filter inductor to the input power supply, which reduce the interference of driver EMI to low voltage power supply.
· A low-pass filter is added to the rectification part of the secondary side power supply, which reduce the interference of the driver to the high-voltage side.
· Use an isolation chip with a common mode immunity of 100kV/μs for signal transmission.
· Optimize the isolation transformer design, and use shielding layer on primary side and secondary side to reduce crosstalk between each other.
· Use Miller clamp to prevent the influence of the switch of the same bridge arm.
2) Low transmission delay
Usually, the application switching frequency of silicon IGBT is less than 40kHZ, and the recommended application switching frequency of SiC MOSFET is greater than 100kHz. The increase of application frequency makes MOS require the driver to provide lower signal delay time. The transmission delay of the SiC MOSFET drive signal should be less than 200ns, and the transmission delay jitter should be less than 20ns, which can be achieved by the following methods.
· Using digital isolation driver chip, the signal transmission delay can reach 50ns, and it has relatively high consistency, and the transmission jitter is less than 5ns.
· Select push-pull chips with low transmission delay and short rise & fall time.
Due to the conductance modulation effect, the on-state specific resistance of high voltage SiC IGBTs is much lower than that of power SiC MOSs, and does not change much as the blocking voltage rating increases. When the conductance modulation effect is fully exerted, the on-state voltage drop of the IGBT drift region is only related to the bipolar diffusion coefficient and bipolar lifetime of the carriers, and will not change with the increase of the on-current. When the operating temperature changes, the on-state voltage drop of the SiC high voltage IGBT decreases with the increase of the junction temperature. This is mainly because the bipolar lifetime of the extra carriers in the SiC epitaxial layer will increase with the increase of temperature. Although the diffusion coefficient will shrink to some extent with the increase of temperature, the greater prolongation of lifetime will eventually make the the bipolar diffusion length increased, thereby reducing the on-state voltage drop. It is especially true in n-channel devices.
This is in sharp contrast to the larger increase in the forward voltage drop of the power MOS at high temperature. Silicon carbide p-channel IGBTs have higher on-state voltage drop than n-channel IGBTs at the same current density due to their larger channel resistance, but their volt-ampere characteristics do not change much with temperature. As for the applications, this is undoubtedly an advantage.

Figure 2. Comparison of characteristics between SiC IGBT and power MOS under the Same Condition of Withstand Voltage of 20kV.
It is not difficult to calculate from the intersection of the equal power consumption curve in the figure and the on-state characteristic curves of these devices: corresponding to the same power consumption of 300W/cm2, the ratio of the on-state current of the silicon carbide IGBT to the silicon carbide power MOS versus p-channel devices and n-channel devices are different, they are 1.5 and 1.8 at room temperature, respectively, and increase to 2.7 and 3.5 at 225°C, indicating that high-voltage and high-current SiC IGBTs are more suitable for high-temperature applications.
In a word, compared with Si IGBT, SiC MOSFET not only improves system efficiency, power density and operating temperature, but also puts forward higher requirements for the driver. In order to make silicon carbide MOSFET better in the system, it is necessary to give SiC MOSFET a appropriate driver.
IGBT is a Darlington pair composed of GTR and MOSFET: part of which is MOSFET driver, and the other part is thick-base PNP transistor.

Figure 3. IGBT Architecture
Its simplified equivalent circuit is shown in the figure below, and RN in the figure is the modulation resistance in the base area of the PNP transistor. It can be clearly seen from this circuit that the IGBT is a composite device of Darlington configuration composed of transistors and MOSFET, where the transistor in the figure is a PNP transistor, and the MOSFET is an N-channel field effect transistor, so the IGBT of this structure is called an N-channel IGBT, and its symbol is N-IGBT. Similarly there are P-channel IGBTs, namely P-IGBTs.

Figure 4. Simplified Equivalent Circuit
The electrical graphic symbols of the IGBT are shown in the figure. IGBT is a field-controlled device, and its turn-on and turn-off are determined by the voltage UGE between the gate and the emitter. When the gate-emitter voltage UCE is positive and greater than the turn-on voltage UCE (th), a channel is formed in the MOSFET and is a PNP. The N-type transistor provides the base current to turn on the IGBT. At this time, the holes (minority carriers) injected into the N- region from the P+ region modulate the conductance of the N- region, reduce the resistance RN of the N- region, and make the IGBT also has a small on-state voltage drop. When no signal or reverse voltage is applied between the gate and emitter, the channel in the MOSFET disappears, the base current of the PNP transistor is cut off, and the IGBT is turned off. It can be seen that the driving principle of IGBT is basically the same as that of MOSFET.
① When UCE is negative: J3 junction is in reverse bias state, and the device is in reverse blocking state.
② When UCE is positive: UC< UTH, the channel cannot be formed, and the device is in a forward blocking state; UG> UTH, an N-channel is formed under the insulating gate, and conductance is generated in the N- region due to the interaction of carriers modulation so that the device is conducting forward.

Figure 5. Hybrid Switch Using Si IGBT and SiC MOSFET
1) ON
The structure of IGBT silicon is very similar to that of power MOSFET, and the main difference is that JGBT adds a P+ substrate and an N+ buffer layer, in terms of it, one MOS drives two bipolar devices (devices with two polarities). The application of the substrate creates a J junction between the P, and N+ regions of the tube. When the positive gate bias causes the inversion of the P base region under the gate, an N-channel is formed, and an electron flow occurs at the same time, and a current is generated exactly in the manner of a power MOSFET. If the voltage produced by this electron flow is in the range of 0.7V, J1 will be forward biased, some holes will be injected into the N- region, and the resistivity between N- and N+ will be adjusted, which reduces the power conduction the total loss of the pass and initiates a second charge flow. The end result is the temporary emergence of two different current topologies within the semiconductor layer: an electron flow (MOSFET current), and a hole current (bipolar). When UCE is greater than the turn-on voltage UCE(th), a channel is formed in the MOSFET to provide base current for the transistor, and the IGBT is turned on.
2) On-State Voltage Drop
The conductance modulation effect reduces the resistance RN and reduces the on-state voltage drop. The so-called on-state voltage drop refers to the tube voltage drop UDS when the IGBT enters the on-state, and this voltage decreases with the rise of UCS.
3) Shut Down
When a negative bias is applied to the gate or the gate voltage is lower than the threshold value, the channel is disabled and no holes are injected into the N-region. In any case, if the current of the MOSFET decreases rapidly during the switching phase, the collector current decreases gradually. This is because there are still minority carriers in the N layer after the commutation starts. This reduction in residual current value (wake) is entirely dependent on the charge density at turn-off, which in turn is related to several factors, such as the number and topology of dopants, layer thickness and temperature. The decay of minority carriers makes the collector current have a wake waveform. Collector current will cause increased power dissipation and cross-conduction problems, especially on devices that use freewheeling diodes.
Considering that the wake is related to the recombination of minority carriers, the current value of the wake should be closely related to the Tc, IC of the chip, and has a close relationship with the mobility of holes. Therefore, depending on the temperature reached, it is feasible to reduce the undesirable effects of this current on the end equipment design. When a back pressure or no signal is applied between the gate and the emitter, the channel in the MOS disappears, the base current of the transistor is cut off, and the IGBT is turned off.
4) Reverse Blocking
When a reverse voltage is applied to the collector, the junction is reverse biased and the depletion layer expands to the N-region. Because the thickness of this layer is reduced too much, an effective blocking ability will not be obtained, so this mechanism is very important. In addition, if the size of this region is increased too much, the voltage drop will continuously increase.
5) Forward Blocking
When the gate and emitter are shorted and a positive voltage is applied at the collector terminal, the junction is controlled by the reverse voltage. At this time, the depletion layer of the N drift region is still subjected to the externally applied voltage.
6) Latch
ICBT has a parasitic PNPN thyristor between the collector and the emitter. Under special conditions, this parasitic device will turn on. This phenomenon increases the amount of current between the collector and the emitter, reduces the controllability of the equivalent MOSFET, and often causes device breakdown problems. The thyristor turn-on phenomenon is known as IGBT latch-up. Specifically, the causes of such defects vary, but are closely related to the state of the devices.
1. Are there SiC IGBT?
Along with the increasing maturity for the material and process of the wide bandgap semiconductor silicon carbide (SiC), the insulated gate bipolar transistor (IGBT) representing the top level of power devices could be fabricated by SiC successfully.
2. Where are SiC MOSFETs used?
The primary automotive applications for SiC power MOSFETs, diodes, and modules are onboard electric vehicle (EV) chargers, DC/DC converters, and drivetrain inverters. Plug-in hybrid EVs and battery EVs (BEVs) use onboard chargers to “refuel” the vehicle battery either at home or at a public charging station.
3. What is SiC MOSFET?
Silicon Carbide (SiC) MOSFETs exhibit higher blocking voltage, lower on state resistance and higher thermal conductivity than their silicon counterparts. SiC MOSFETs are designed and essentially processed the same way as silicon MOSFETs.
4. Can MOSFET replace IGBT?
Due to the higher usable current density of IGBTs, it can usually handle two to three times more current than a typical MOSFET it replaces. This means that a single IGBT device can replace multiple MOSFETs in parallel operation or any of the super-large single power MOSFETs that are available today.
5. What are the advantages of silicon carbide?
Silicon carbide MOSFETs have a critical breakdown strength that is 10x of silicon, and silicon carbide MOSFETs can operate at much higher temperatures, provide higher current density, experience reduced switching losses, and support higher switching frequencies.
6. What are the advantages of silicon carbide (SiC) over silicon (Si)?
The advantage of SiC starts in the material itself having a 10x higher dielectric breakdown field strength, 2x higher electron saturation velocity, 3x higher energy bad gap and 3x higher thermal conductivity than Silicon.
7. What is the difference between silicon and silicon carbide?
Silicon has a breakdown voltage of around 600V, while silicon carbide can withstand voltages 5-10 times higher. ... Silicon carbide can switch at nearly ten times the rate of silicon, which results in smaller control circuitry.
8. What is SiC in semiconductor?
SiC (silicon carbide) is a compound semiconductor composed of silicon and carbide. SiC provides a number of advantages over silicon, including 10x the breakdown electric field strength, 3x the band gap, and enabling a wider range of p- and n-type control required for device construction.
9. Which is better MOSFET or IGBT?
When compared to the IGBT, a power MOSFET has the advantages of higher commutation speed and greater efficiency during operation at low voltages. What's more, it can sustain a high blocking voltage and maintain a high current. ... The IGBT is also a three terminal (gate, collector, and emitter) full-controlled switch.
10. Why use an IGBT instead of a MOSFET?
The main advantages of IGBT over a Power MOSFET and a BJT are: 1. It has a very low on-state voltage drop due to conductivity modulation and has superior on-state current density. ... It canbe easily controlled as compared to current controlled devices (thyristor, BJT) in high voltage and high current applications.
11. Why is MOSFET preferred?
Mosfet provides a very good isolation between the gate and the other two terminals compared to bjt. Mosfet can handle more power compared to BJT. The mosfet has a very low power loss and a high speed. Voltage signals can easily operate a mosfet, so it is used in many digital circuits.
12. Where are MOSFETs used?
Power MOSFETs are commonly used in automotive electronics, particularly as switching devices in electronic control units, and as power converters in modern electric vehicles. The insulated-gate bipolar transistor (IGBT), a hybrid MOS-bipolar transistor, is also used for a wide variety of applications.
13. Why IGBT is very popular nowadays?
With its lower on-state resistance and conduction losses as well as its ability to switch high voltages at high frequencies without damage makes the Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistor ideal for driving inductive loads such as coil windings, electromagnets and DC motors.
14. How many terminals are in a MOSFET?
four terminals
The MOSFET has four terminals: drain, source, gate, and body or substrate.
15. Why is IGBT bipolar?
IGBTs is a bipolar device that utilizes two types of carriers, electrons and holes, resulting from the complex configuration that features a MOSFET structure at the input block and bipolar output, making it a transistor that can achieve low saturation voltage (similar to low ON resistance MOSFETs) with relatively fast.
16. How many types of IGBT are there?
two types
Insulated Gate Bipolar Junction Transistor (IGBTs) are normally classified into two types. (ii) Punch Through [PT-IGBT]. These IGBTs are also referred to as symmetrical and asymmetrical IGBTs. These varieties of IGBT differ widely with regard to their fabrication technology, structural details etc.
17. What is full MOSFET?
MOSFET stands for metal-oxide-semiconductor field-effect transistor. It is a field-effect transistor with a MOS structure. Typically, the MOSFET is a three-terminal device with gate (G), drain (D) and source (S) terminals.
18. How does an IGBT work as a switch?
As defined by being a transistor, an IGBT is a semiconductor with three terminals which work as a switch for moving electrical current. Just as the word “gate” suggests, when voltage is applied to the gate, it opens or “turns on” and creates a path for current to flow between the layers.
19. Can I use transistor instead of MOSFET?
It very much depends on the application. BJTs can be cheaper than FETs. This is especially true for high voltage switching where the much larger die area of FETs make them much more expensive.
20. Can IGBT conduct in reverse direction?
No. The IGBT cannot conduct current in the reverse direction (from emitter to collector) even with a positive Vge applied to it, because it has a bipolar-type structure. ... However, the gate has no control over this reverse current flow; it is simply the forward biasing of the diode that allows it.
Ivy is a seasoned writer with over 6 years of experience in the semiconductor electronics industry. She possesses a wealth of knowledge in the field, coupled with cutting-edge creative concepts. Ivy is a distinguished author with unique insights and a remarkable writing style.
Join our mailing list!
Be the first to know about new products, special offers, and more.
Recent Posts
We'd love to hear from you! Feel free to share your thoughts and comments below. Rest assured, your email address will remain private.
© 2008-2026 kynix.com all rights reserved.